OpenClaw/Hermes dual-run compare — 2026-04-30 09:15:53

Verdict: OpenClaw 사망 보류

Rule: stale OpenClaw evidence age >= 7d => STALE_DEATH_CANDIDATE. Otherwise comparable artifact similarity >= 95% => OpenClaw death OK candidate. This script is read-only and does not trigger Telegram/API sends.

candidate	status	OpenClaw age	similarity	OpenClaw latest	Hermes latest
daily-context-snapshot	COMPARE_ONLY	6.0d	83.3%	2026-04-24 13:08:43	2026-04-24 14:11:49
intelligence-discovery-filter	COMPARE_ONLY	-	2.8%	2026-04-24 09:28:21	2026-04-25 01:54:40
gmail-newsletter	STALE_DEATH_CANDIDATE	18.1d	2.1%	2026-04-24 07:00:51	2026-04-30 06:50:00
cmux-cowork	STALE_DEATH_CANDIDATE	17.8d	7.0%	2026-04-15 04:09:28	2026-04-23 04:05:40
analyst-macro	STALE_DEATH_CANDIDATE	19.9d	5.6%	2026-04-15 07:06:24	2026-04-30 07:12:20
analyst-fundamental	STALE_DEATH_CANDIDATE	19.9d	1.7%	2026-04-15 07:18:39	2026-04-30 07:18:20
analyst-technical	STALE_DEATH_CANDIDATE	19.9d	0.0%	-	2026-04-30 07:20:03
analyst-pm	STALE_DEATH_CANDIDATE	19.9d	2.0%	2026-04-15 07:44:10	2026-04-30 07:35:05

Details

Daily context snapshot

• OpenClaw jobs: daily-context-snapshot: enabled=False schedule=0 9,22 * * * last_run=2026-04-24 09:29:30
• Hermes jobs: daily-context-snapshot: enabled=True schedule=0 9,22 * * * last_run=2026-04-30 09:00:05
• OpenClaw newest: /Users/ron/.openclaw/workspace/memory/daily-context-snapshot/latest.json (2026-04-24 13:08:43)
• Hermes newest: /Users/ron/.hermes/workspace/memory/daily-context-snapshot/latest.json (2026-04-24 14:11:49)
• OpenClaw operational age: 6.0d; stale verdict: no
• Similarity: 83.3%
• Safety: safe: local JSON snapshot only; OpenClaw stays enabled for 1-week observation while Hermes writes parallel artifact.

Intelligence discovery filter

• OpenClaw jobs: intelligence-discovery-filter: enabled=True schedule=0 */6 * * * last_run=-
• Hermes jobs: ocRESTORE-intelligence-cluster: enabled=True schedule=0 1 * * * last_run=2026-04-30 02:00:35
• OpenClaw newest: /Users/ron/.openclaw/workspace/memory/filtered-ideas/filtered_2026-04-24_0928.json (2026-04-24 09:28:21)
• Hermes newest: /Users/ron/.hermes/workspace/memory/filtered-ideas/filtered_2026-04-25_0154.json (2026-04-25 01:54:40)
• OpenClaw operational age: -; stale verdict: no
• Similarity: 2.8%
• Safety: safe to compare artifacts only; output count differs materially, so keep both for 1-week trend before OpenClaw death.

Gmail newsletter collector

• OpenClaw jobs: gmail-newsletter-collector: enabled=False schedule=47 6 * * * last_run=2026-04-12 06:47:01
• Hermes jobs: ocAQ-AQ004-gmail-newsletter-command: enabled=True schedule=47 6 * * * last_run=2026-04-30 06:50:14
• OpenClaw newest: /Users/ron/.openclaw/workspace/memory/gmail-newsletter/state.json (2026-04-24 07:00:51)
• Hermes newest: /Users/ron/.hermes/workspace/memory/gmail-newsletter/state.json (2026-04-30 06:50:00)
• OpenClaw operational age: 18.1d; stale verdict: yes
• Similarity: 2.1%
• Safety: caution: Gmail stateful collector may mark mail processed; keep OpenClaw silent/disabled unless a dry-run flag is confirmed.

cmux_supervisor / cowork

• OpenClaw jobs: cowork-daily-review: enabled=False schedule=30 9 * * 1-5 last_run=2026-04-06 09:31:13
  cowork-lite: enabled=False schedule=23 7,10,13,16,19,22 * * * last_run=2026-04-12 13:00:21
  cowork-full: enabled=False schedule=0 4 * * * last_run=2026-04-12 04:00:31
• Hermes jobs: -
• OpenClaw newest: /Users/ron/.openclaw/workspace/memory/cowork-history/latest.json (2026-04-15 04:09:28)
• Hermes newest: /Users/ron/.hermes/workspace/memory/cowork-history/latest.json (2026-04-23 04:05:40)
• OpenClaw operational age: 17.8d; stale verdict: yes
• Similarity: 7.0%
• Safety: unsafe: cowork jobs are agent/prompt jobs with side effects; compare artifacts only until Hermes equivalent is explicit.

Analyst macro

• OpenClaw jobs: analyst-macro-agent: enabled=False schedule=5 7 * * 1-5 last_run=2026-04-10 12:01:40
• Hermes jobs: -
• OpenClaw newest: /Users/ron/.openclaw/workspace/memory/analyst-macro/latest.json (2026-04-15 07:06:24)
• Hermes newest: /Users/ron/.hermes/workspace/memory/analyst-macro/latest.json (2026-04-30 07:12:20)
• OpenClaw operational age: 19.9d; stale verdict: yes
• Similarity: 5.6%
• Safety: unsafe: legacy OpenClaw analyst prompt can send/consume LLM; keep disabled, compare artifacts.

Analyst fundamental

• OpenClaw jobs: analyst-fundamental-agent: enabled=False schedule=28 7 * * 1-5 last_run=2026-04-10 12:19:11
• Hermes jobs: -
• OpenClaw newest: /Users/ron/.openclaw/workspace/memory/analyst-fundamental/latest.json (2026-04-15 07:18:39)
• Hermes newest: /Users/ron/.hermes/workspace/memory/analyst-fundamental/latest.json (2026-04-30 07:18:20)
• OpenClaw operational age: 19.9d; stale verdict: yes
• Similarity: 1.7%
• Safety: unsafe: legacy OpenClaw analyst prompt can send/consume LLM; keep disabled, compare artifacts.

Analyst technical

• OpenClaw jobs: analyst-technical-agent: enabled=False schedule=32 7 * * 1-5 last_run=2026-04-10 12:18:15
• Hermes jobs: -
• OpenClaw newest: - (-)
• Hermes newest: /Users/ron/.hermes/workspace/memory/analyst-technical/latest.json (2026-04-30 07:20:03)
• OpenClaw operational age: 19.9d; stale verdict: yes
• Similarity: 0.0%
• Safety: unsafe: legacy OpenClaw analyst prompt can send/consume LLM; keep disabled, compare artifacts.

Analyst PM

• OpenClaw jobs: analyst-pm-agent: enabled=False schedule=55 7 * * 1-5 last_run=2026-04-10 12:20:10
• Hermes jobs: -
• OpenClaw newest: /Users/ron/.openclaw/workspace/memory/analyst-pm/latest.json (2026-04-15 07:44:10)
• Hermes newest: /Users/ron/.hermes/workspace/memory/analyst-pm/latest.json (2026-04-30 07:35:05)
• OpenClaw operational age: 19.9d; stale verdict: yes
• Similarity: 2.0%
• Safety: unsafe: legacy OpenClaw analyst prompt can send/consume LLM; keep disabled, compare artifacts.

DONE