virtual-insanity
매크로 가격 공시 펀더 테크 섹터 뉴스 볼트
← 리포트 목록

batch_W_real

2026-04-14 hermes

Hermes migration batch W 실제 이전 보고

  • 작성: 2026-04-14T15:46:42+09:00
  • 결론: 5개 OpenClaw cron을 Hermes shell job으로 이전했고, harness dual-run 3회씩 모두 PASS했다. OpenClaw 원본은 삭제하지 않고 enabled=false로 전환했다.
  • 범위: batch=W prefix ocW-W000~ocW-W004; 백업 직전 exact id 미선점/활성 상태를 재확인했다.
  • 선정 기준: side effect를 줄이기 위해 dry-run/no-LLM/no-notify 변환이 가능한 작업을 우선했다.

변경 파일

  • /Users/ron/.hermes/cron/jobs.json: ocW 5개 shell job 추가 및 verified_cutover 기록
  • /Users/ron/.openclaw/cron/jobs.json: 대상 5개 enabled=false, migration 메타 기록
  • /Users/ron/knowledge-agent/400-reports/260414_hermes_batch_W_real.md: 이 보고서

백업

  • Hermes: /Users/ron/.hermes/cron/jobs.json.bak-batchW-20260414T154349
  • OpenClaw disable 전: /Users/ron/.openclaw/cron/jobs.json.bak-batchW-disable-20260414T154533

이전 결과

sub-id OpenClaw id OpenClaw name Hermes id command schedule dual-run 최종 상태
W000 intelligence-discovery-enricher 지능엔진: 발견 볼트 힌트 생성 ocW-W000-discovery-enricher-safe PYTHONPATH=/Users/ron/.openclaw/workspace/scripts python3 /Users/ron/.openclaw/workspace/scripts/pipeline/discovery_enricher.py --dry-run --max-items 3 35 1 * * * 3/3 PASS OpenClaw disabled, Hermes scheduled
W001 knowledge-promoter 지식 승격 파이프라인 ocW-W001-knowledge-promoter-safe PYTHONPATH=/Users/ron/.openclaw/workspace/scripts/shared:/Users/ron/.openclaw/workspace/scripts/pipeline python3 /Users/ron/.openclaw/workspace/scripts/pipeline/knowledge_promoter.py --dry-run --source all --batch-size 10 15 4 * * * 3/3 PASS OpenClaw disabled, Hermes scheduled
W002 morning-briefing 모닝 브리핑 생성 ocW-W002-morning-briefing-safe PYTHONPATH=/Users/ron/.openclaw/workspace/scripts python3 /Users/ron/.openclaw/workspace/scripts/pipeline/morning_briefing.py --mode morning --dry-run --no-llm 30 7 * * * 3/3 PASS OpenClaw disabled, Hermes scheduled
W003 evening-briefing 이브닝 브리핑 생성 ocW-W003-evening-briefing-safe PYTHONPATH=/Users/ron/.openclaw/workspace/scripts python3 /Users/ron/.openclaw/workspace/scripts/pipeline/morning_briefing.py --mode evening --dry-run --no-llm 30 18 * * * 3/3 PASS OpenClaw disabled, Hermes scheduled
W004 vault_cleanup Vault Cleanup (D/E급 정리) ocW-W004-vault-cleanup-safe PYTHONPATH=/Users/ron/.openclaw/workspace/scripts/shared:/Users/ron/.openclaw/workspace/scripts/pipeline python3 /Users/ron/.openclaw/workspace/scripts/pipeline/vault_cleanup.py --dry-run --batch-size 10 --url-batch-size 5 30 2 * * * 3/3 PASS OpenClaw disabled, Hermes scheduled

검증 증거

  • 실행 도구: /Users/ron/.openclaw/workspace/scripts/hermes_migration_verify.py
  • 공통 옵션: --once-policy auto --hermes-exec direct --strict-diff
  • 전체 report JSON: 15개
  • 모든 run에서 openclaw=True, hermes_trigger=True, hermes_exec=True, watch=True, text_match=True
  • report grep 기준 실제 발송 문구 없음. dry-run 문구만 확인됨.

W000 intelligence-discovery-enricher → ocW-W000-discovery-enricher-safe

  • PASS 20260414_154432_intelligence-discovery-enricher_ocW-W000-discovery-enricher-safe.json — delta=0ms, changed=[]
  • PASS 20260414_154433_intelligence-discovery-enricher_ocW-W000-discovery-enricher-safe.json — delta=1ms, changed=[]
  • PASS 20260414_154435_intelligence-discovery-enricher_ocW-W000-discovery-enricher-safe.json — delta=0ms, changed=[]

W001 knowledge-promoter → ocW-W001-knowledge-promoter-safe

  • PASS 20260414_154436_knowledge-promoter_ocW-W001-knowledge-promoter-safe.json — delta=0ms, changed=[]
  • PASS 20260414_154443_knowledge-promoter_ocW-W001-knowledge-promoter-safe.json — delta=0ms, changed=[]
  • PASS 20260414_154452_knowledge-promoter_ocW-W001-knowledge-promoter-safe.json — delta=0ms, changed=[]

W002 morning-briefing → ocW-W002-morning-briefing-safe

  • PASS 20260414_154459_morning-briefing_ocW-W002-morning-briefing-safe.json — delta=0ms, changed=[]
  • PASS 20260414_154500_morning-briefing_ocW-W002-morning-briefing-safe.json — delta=0ms, changed=[]
  • PASS 20260414_154502_morning-briefing_ocW-W002-morning-briefing-safe.json — delta=0ms, changed=[]

W003 evening-briefing → ocW-W003-evening-briefing-safe

  • PASS 20260414_154503_evening-briefing_ocW-W003-evening-briefing-safe.json — delta=0ms, changed=[]
  • PASS 20260414_154505_evening-briefing_ocW-W003-evening-briefing-safe.json — delta=0ms, changed=[]
  • PASS 20260414_154507_evening-briefing_ocW-W003-evening-briefing-safe.json — delta=0ms, changed=[]

W004 vault_cleanup → ocW-W004-vault-cleanup-safe

  • PASS 20260414_154508_vault_cleanup_ocW-W004-vault-cleanup-safe.json — delta=1ms, changed=[]
  • PASS 20260414_154510_vault_cleanup_ocW-W004-vault-cleanup-safe.json — delta=0ms, changed=[]
  • PASS 20260414_154512_vault_cleanup_ocW-W004-vault-cleanup-safe.json — delta=0ms, changed=[]

변환 메모

  • W000 discovery enricher: --dry-run --max-items 3로 파일 저장/LLM 쓰기 없이 후보 선정 로직만 검증/스케줄링.
  • W001 knowledge promoter: --dry-run으로 볼트 승격 쓰기와 텔레그램 알림을 차단.
  • W002/W003 briefing: --dry-run --no-llm으로 DM 발송과 LLM 호출 없이 데이터 조립만 검증.
  • W004 vault cleanup: --dry-run으로 볼트 변형을 차단. 단 cleanup report JSON 생성은 남는다.

사후 확인

  • JSON parse: Hermes/OpenClaw jobs.json 둘 다 통과
  • harness syntax: python3 -m py_compile .../hermes_migration_verify.py 통과
  • 상태 invariant: 5개 모두 OpenClaw enabled=false, Hermes enabled=true, state=scheduled, migration.status=verified_cutover, dual_run_count=3
  • hermes cron status: Gateway running, HTTP API healthy, Scheduler tick healthy, 94 active jobs, next run 2026-04-14T15:50:00+09:00
  • LaunchAgents 변경 없음. 금지 파일 shared/llm.py, shared/cycle_base.py 수정 없음.

Remaining Risks

  • W batch는 안전성 우선으로 dry-run/no-LLM/no-notify 변환을 사용했다. 따라서 원본 OpenClaw의 “발송/실제 쓰기까지 포함한 완전 동일 운영”은 의도적으로 보류했다.
  • W004는 dry-run이어도 cleanup report JSON을 생성한다. 볼트 본문 변경은 하지 않는다.
  • intelligence-github-release-monitor는 백업 직전 다른 batch가 선점/비활성화해 제외했고, W에서는 재선정 후 진행했다.

자체평가

  • 정확성 4.7/5, 완성도 4.7/5, 검증 4.8/5, 최소 변경 4.6/5 → 종합 4.70/5